It’s a fickle situation writer’s often find themselves in when it comes to the editing process. Here you are with your finished draft, thinking it’s totally aces and ready to publish.
Then you read it…
Oops.
When you leave your first draft, you’ve told the story as you envisioned it from the beginning. Before typing that first word, this is what was intended – in your mind – and, of course, it is absolutely without fault.
The funny thing is, that over the course of that draft you’ve learned a thing or two about what your story is REALLY about. You’ve lived with these characters, recognized their movements, felt their anguish and heartbreak as well as their joy and triumph. Those lessons, those feelings, can sometimes influence the self-editing process more than we ever imagined.
And it can be a good thing.
It opens doors to building better scenes.
What was wrong with my original scene?
Maybe nothing at all. The truth is, you may simply realize there is a BETTER way to develop a relationship or work through a heavy bit of exposition. This might come from a character perspective, or a change in their arc during the course of the draft.
On the other hand, there are some very real reasons to change a scene completely. For example, I recently finished reading The Resurrection of Jean Grey by Matthew Rosenberg. I enjoy Matthew Rosenberg’s work typically. He knows his characters and creates interesting situations that play to their strengths.
Not this time around.
In no less than three – count ’em THREE – separate occasions during the narrative, he decides to fall back for a mission briefing scene. In the same location. With the same people. Each time, they are somewhere else and decide this conversation needs to happen. So they head to the briefing room and hash it out. It slows the plot to a grinding halt. Actually, it’s worse than that – it is such a reversal that it sucks the life out of the book completely.
Now I get it. There are deadline constraints. There are reasons why these scenes felt right to him. It shows Kitty Pryde’s leadership. There’s focus on the interplay between the teams. Or maybe it just looks cool showing every X-Man possible in a single shot.
But this example needed new locales, new situations, in order to offer the exposition required to advance the plot. It really, really did.
Your story might need the same.
I know mine do from time to time. There are certain situations that just feel right and natural. It’s a comfort zone and I fall into the trap every once in awhile. Too many office scenes. Too many warehouse or alley scenes. There are a million, billion places to sit and have a conversation. Why make it the same place every single time?
Everyone should look twice at their scenes for improvement.
From the first-time novelist to the seasoned vet, each of us can stand to take a closer look at our scene breakdown. Is there a way to punch up this scene? To make it more exciting or visually interesting to the reader? Does it hit the right character beat or is the environment causing a different vibe entirely?
Play with the dynamic. Switch things around.
Don’t use the downtown high-rise. Make it a museum. Look for different angles that explore character and theme.
Have fun with it. Because if you’re having a good time in the scene so will your reader.